Monday, November 10, 2014

On the Town

This past Sunday I took in a performance of On the Town at the Lyric Theater in midtown. The original production of On the Town originally premiered on Broadway in 1944, and now it’s being revived on the Great White Way.

The Cast of On the Town - Source: Broadway.com

I was excited to see the show because I had heard such great things about it. The production currently on Broadway was mounted last summer at the Barrington Stage Company in Pittsfield, MA, and it received rave reviews from critics. So I had high expectations, especially for the dancing which has been a trademark of the show since it’s beginning in 1944.

Right from the outset, the show did a marvelous job at making an experience, something that is crucial to creating a successful show. Music from the 1930’s (the time period of the show), flowed throughout the lobby. Also in the library was an old-fashioned candy and soda shop, transporting the audience immediately into the world of the show. Inside the theater, with the American Flag curtain covering the stage, the orchestra played the national anthem while the audience stood and sang. And with that, we were transported to a different time, both in life and in musical theater.

                                                                                         The Cast of On the Town - Source: Broadway.com


It was the transportation to a different time in musical theater, which is where On the Town stumbled slightly. The show began with a big song and dance number as expected, which did not disappoint. However, many of the big numbers after that were presented as dances (in ballet style) without singing. This was the style of many shows at the time of On the Town’s original premiere, but is not the custom today. While the dances were beautiful, it would have been nice to see them follow more of a modern song and dance style. Speaking of songs, while many of them were catchy, I didn’t leave the theater remembering many of them. The dialogue between them included some entertaining jokes that got better as the plot went along, however many of them would have landed with more weight had script gone through a bit more updating. The numbers were, however, creatively and intriguingly staged, especially the romantic dance number which took place in an imagined Coney Island boxing ring.

The cast, including the ensemble, were extraordinary dancers, not only in physicality but also in expression, which I could see from the last row of the theater. Where they fell short was in their chemistry together and I often felt that the lead actors were on different pages, especially in terms of their comedy. Since On the Town’s opening night took place October 16th, they could just need more time to get used to each other.

The Cast of On the Town - Source: Broadway.com

The interesting thing about this show, was the producers’ decision to put the show in the Lyric Theater. The Lyric is the largest theater on Broadway at 1,874 seats. Being in the last row of the theater, the show did not fully reach me, nor did I feel like I was having a unified experience with the rest of the audience. A show of this nature would have played better in a smaller venue where the audience could have been drawn in more significantly by the show’s old fashioned charm.


Overall, On the Town is an entertaining and fluffy production, but it doesn’t go much deeper than that.

Click here for a preview of On the Town

No comments:

Post a Comment